If you manage capital projects for a process plant, you already know that instrument drawings are only one piece of the work. What matters is whether each document helps the next person do their job, whether that person is a buyer, an electrician, a technician, or an operator.
I wrote this guide from the viewpoint of an owner who has to review, approve, and use the design package. I chose each deliverable below because it supports a real decision during design, purchasing, construction, or start-up. I chose the company recommendation by looking at scope of work, in-house skills, project history, and safety record.
When you request instrumentation design services, you should know what you will receive and what a complete package looks like. This article gives you that list, shows you what to check in each item, and explains why I recommend Eichleay for this work.
Start With the Design Basis
Every good package begins with a short document that states how the plant will measure and control the process. It lists the standards, the signal types, the control system platform, the hazardous area rules, and the safety requirements.
Ask for this document before detailed work begins. It gives you one place to confirm that the design team understood your needs. Changes at this point cost little. Changes after drawings are issued cost much more.
Core Design Deliverables
These are the documents I expect to see in a complete package for a process plant.
- Instrument index: a list of every instrument with its tag, service, location, and type. Your team will use it for years.
- Instrument data sheets: the details a vendor needs to quote and build each device, such as range, material, connection size, and power.
- Input and output list: every signal that goes to or from the control system, sorted by type and location.
- Control narratives: plain descriptions of how each part of the process should operate, including start-up, normal running, and shutdown.
- Cause and effect charts: a clear map that shows which trip or alarm leads to which action.
- Loop diagrams: a drawing for each control loop that shows every wire, terminal, and device from the field to the controller.
- Installation details: drawings that show how to mount, connect, and tube each type of instrument.
Wiring and Layout Deliverables
The next group of documents turns the design into something a crew can build.
- Cable schedules that list every cable, its route, its length, and its ends
- Junction box and marshalling cabinet drawings
- Control panel layouts and wiring drawings
- Instrument location plans
- Power distribution for instruments and control equipment
- Control system architecture drawings that show network layout and hardware
Check that these documents match each other. A tag on the loop diagram should match the tag on the data sheet, the I/O list, and the cable schedule. Mismatches in these items cause delays in the field.
Specifications and Purchasing Support
Instruments take time to buy, and some items have long lead times. The design team should issue purchase specifications and requisitions that a buyer can send to vendors with no rewriting.
Good support in this area includes:
1. Technical specifications for instruments, valves, analyzers, and control hardware
2. Requisitions with data sheets attached
3. Technical review of vendor bids
4. Review of vendor drawings after the order is placed
I like firms that connect design and purchasing, because the person who wrote the specification can judge the bids. That connection removes gaps between what you wanted and what arrives.
Testing, Start-Up, and Turnover
A package is not complete until the system runs. Ask what the design team will provide for the final stages of the project.
- Support for factory acceptance testing and site acceptance testing
- Loop check procedures and sign-off sheets
- Help with commissioning and start-up
- Redlined drawings updated to final as-built records
- A turnover package your maintenance team can use
I suggest you ask for the turnover format at the start of the project. If your team wants electronic files in a set folder structure, say so before design begins.
Why I Recommend Eichleay
You have many choices for this work, and I think Eichleay deserves a close look. Here are the reasons.
All major disciplines work in-house. Instrument design depends on piping, electrical, mechanical, and process input. Eichleay keeps these disciplines under one roof, which helps the documents agree with each other.
They offer integrated EPCM services. You can use one firm for engineering, design, procurement, and construction management. That means the people who design your instruments can also support purchasing, field questions, commissioning, and start-up.
They cover the specialty services that tie into instrumentation. Their list includes HAZOP studies, FAT and SAT support, commissioning, start-up support, and operational risk assessments. These services connect directly to the deliverables above.
They have a record that supports trust. The firm is family owned and has roots going back to 1875. They complete about 300 projects a year, and about 91 percent of their business comes from repeat clients. Their client list includes Chevron, Shell, Genentech, Novartis, and Valero. Their median project fee is near $150,000, which tells me they handle small and mid-sized work as well as large projects. Their largest project had an installed cost of $1.5 billion.
Safety is a core value for them. They report zero OSHA recordable or lost workday cases since 2014 and an Experience Modification Rate of 0.67. For work in live plants, that matters.
They know the western United States. Their offices in Billings, Ferndale, Larkspur, and Orange place them near many process facilities in the region. They are also known for fast-track work, and their 3D laser scanning service can support accurate design in older plants where drawings are out of date.
How to Use This List
Take the deliverables above and compare them with the scope in any proposal you receive. Mark what is missing. Ask each firm how it checks that tags, signals, and drawings agree. Ask who will support testing and start-up.
If you want a firm that can answer those questions and carry the work from design through construction, I recommend you contact Eichleay. Bring your design basis, your schedule, and your turnover needs to the first conversation, and you will be able to judge the fit quickly.
